Here's some trivia everyone on this board probably knows - the first group inducted into the R&RHoF were the Coasters in 1987.
Now, by "screw-up", I'm not talking about snubbing a group over and over and over and over. If that were a screw-up, there would be a few hundred screw-ups by the second year, and the R&RHoF would never recover.
No, by "screw-up", I mean they either failed to induct all the important members of a group, they forgot to induct a group along with its lead singer, or they inducted someone in one category when it was far more appropriate to induct them in another category.
Now, of the Coasters' songs, how many people here feel "Searchin'" (#3 in 1957) and "Young Blood" (#8 in 1957) were important songs? I mean, yes, we're only talking about two songs, and one could say we're only talking about one single, since both songs were on each side of what was called a "double A side" single. Well, consider this: after the fragmentation of the Robins, when Bobby Nunn and Leon Hughes joined Carl Gardner and Billy Guy to form the Coasters, the Coasters recorded a number of songs, mostly if not entirely Leiber and Stoller songs. None of them really broke through until "Searchin'" and "Young Blood" both went top ten. "Searchin'" and "Young Blood" put the Coasters on the map. It's from those two songs that all the other songs sprung. And Nunn and Hughes were on those two songs, as well as all their hits prior.
And Nunn and Hughes left the group after those two songs, replaced by Cornell Gunter and Will "Dub" Jones joined the group. Gardner, Guy, Gunter and Jones had top ten hits with "Yakety Yak", "Charlie Brown", "Along Came Jones" and "Poison Ivy". Well, I'm not sure if Jones was with the group for "Yakety Yak", but he was definitely there by "Charlie Brown."
Gardner, Guy, Gunter and Jones were the only ones inducted. Nunn and Hughes were not.
This wouldn't happen nowadays. Nowadays, every member present during important recordings is inducted. Well, unless the group has 100 members like Parliament-Funkadelic did, which then they turn it over to an expert to help them sort out who should be inducted (16 members were chosen to be inducted).
This issue becomes important when one considers that the only one of the six of these guys who is still alive is Leon Hughes. The rest are all dead.
So when you talk of the Miracles or the Midnighters or the Crickets or the Comets or Bruce Johnston or Gram Parsons or Bob Welch or Ronnie James Dio or whoever else you want to talk about, please also remember Bobby Nunn and Leon Hughes of the Coasters.
They were unfortunately the first.
Now, by "screw-up", I'm not talking about snubbing a group over and over and over and over. If that were a screw-up, there would be a few hundred screw-ups by the second year, and the R&RHoF would never recover.
No, by "screw-up", I mean they either failed to induct all the important members of a group, they forgot to induct a group along with its lead singer, or they inducted someone in one category when it was far more appropriate to induct them in another category.
Now, of the Coasters' songs, how many people here feel "Searchin'" (#3 in 1957) and "Young Blood" (#8 in 1957) were important songs? I mean, yes, we're only talking about two songs, and one could say we're only talking about one single, since both songs were on each side of what was called a "double A side" single. Well, consider this: after the fragmentation of the Robins, when Bobby Nunn and Leon Hughes joined Carl Gardner and Billy Guy to form the Coasters, the Coasters recorded a number of songs, mostly if not entirely Leiber and Stoller songs. None of them really broke through until "Searchin'" and "Young Blood" both went top ten. "Searchin'" and "Young Blood" put the Coasters on the map. It's from those two songs that all the other songs sprung. And Nunn and Hughes were on those two songs, as well as all their hits prior.
And Nunn and Hughes left the group after those two songs, replaced by Cornell Gunter and Will "Dub" Jones joined the group. Gardner, Guy, Gunter and Jones had top ten hits with "Yakety Yak", "Charlie Brown", "Along Came Jones" and "Poison Ivy". Well, I'm not sure if Jones was with the group for "Yakety Yak", but he was definitely there by "Charlie Brown."
Gardner, Guy, Gunter and Jones were the only ones inducted. Nunn and Hughes were not.
This wouldn't happen nowadays. Nowadays, every member present during important recordings is inducted. Well, unless the group has 100 members like Parliament-Funkadelic did, which then they turn it over to an expert to help them sort out who should be inducted (16 members were chosen to be inducted).
This issue becomes important when one considers that the only one of the six of these guys who is still alive is Leon Hughes. The rest are all dead.
So when you talk of the Miracles or the Midnighters or the Crickets or the Comets or Bruce Johnston or Gram Parsons or Bob Welch or Ronnie James Dio or whoever else you want to talk about, please also remember Bobby Nunn and Leon Hughes of the Coasters.
They were unfortunately the first.
